Carbon Transfer

old process, new questions

Jean-Sébastien Caux

A brief intro

Historical bullet points

1827 Nicéphore Niépce Photo from camera+lens
1839 Sir John Herschel Prints/fixing
1839 Mungo Ponton Potassium dichromate
1840 Edmond Becquerel (builds on Ponton)
1852 William Henry Fox Talbot Dichromated gelatine
1855 Alphonse Poitevin Printing (à la carbon)

Historical bullet points (II)

1855 James Clerk Maxwell 3-color process
1861 Maxwell/Thomas Sutton 1st color photo
1861_Maxwell_Sutton_Tartan_Ribbon.jpg

Historical bullet points (III)

1863 Joseph Wilson Swan Carbon as we know it
[lots of people] [process remains unchanged]
< ~ 1960 [lots of businesses] [patents/lawsuits]
   
1993 Charles Berger UltraStable process
? ? ?

General qualities of carbon prints

  • optimal permanence
  • ideal linear characteristic curve
  • textured surface ("relief")
  • variety of pigments
  • variety of final supports

A pioneer: Julia Margaret Cameron

Julia_Margaret_Cameron__John_Herschel.jpg Sir John Herschel (1867)

Julia_Margaret_Cameron__Charles_Darwin.jpg Charles Darwin (1868)

What you need to make a carbon print

The negative

Silver gelatine negative (slice, side view)

negative.svg

Transmission density profile:

negative_TD.svg

Glop

A mixture of:

  • water
  • gelatine
  • ink
  • sensitizer
  • (+ sugar, glycerine, thymol)
glop.jpg

Carbon tissue

i.e. the "photosensitive paper"

tissue.svg

Pouring tissue

Making a carbon print

Exposure

Neg + tissue sandwich exposed to UV

(contact printing only; no enlargement)

exposure.svg

Post-exposure

The exposed parts have hardened (top-down according to common lore)

post_exposure.svg

Mating

The exposed tissue (flipped) is mated with a final paper support

mating.svg

Development

Tissue/paper sandwich plunged in hot (40C) water

development.svg

The tissue support is peeled away

The non-hardened glop melts away

The hardened part adheres to the final paper support

Post-development

The result is hardened gelatine with embedded ink,

on an archival paper support

post_development.svg

producing the final photographic image

Single transfer

carbon_transfer_process_4.svg

Double transfer

carbon_transfer_process_5.svg

Multiple transfer

A more advanced method making use of multiple transfers onto a temporary support

Enables:

  • contrast/tone control
  • deepest blacks
  • more relief
  • color printing

Problems and pitfalls

Carbon transfer is perhaps the most

finicky traditional photographic process

  • highlight loss (percolation threshold?)
  • bubbles (from water, Nitrogen)
  • adherence (flagging, frilling, delamination)
  • exposure control
  • contrast control

Factors affecting the process

  • gelatine composition
  • ink type/concentration
  • sensitizer type/concentration
  • light source
  • exposure
  • support type (adherence)
  • mating bath (temp, duration)
  • development bath (temp, duration, agitation)

From practice to theory

My objective: to understand

the "microscopics" of the process

  • photoinduced cross-linking
  • interplay between constituents
  • dynamics of development

Gelatine

Hamster_Huey.png

Gelatine composition: 19 amino acids

  • glycine (Gly) 26-34% – promotes close packing
  • proline (Pro) 10-18% – inhibits conformation
  • hydroxyproline (Hyp) 7-15%
  • alanine (Ala) 8-11%
  • arginine (Arg) 8-9%
  • aspartic acid (Asp) 6-7%
  • glutamic acid (Glu) 10-12%

Glycine

C2H5NO2
Glycine_Conformer3D_large.png

In aqueous solution, newtral pH:

Glycine zwitterion 2-Azaniumylacetate_Conformer3D_large.png

Sensitizers

Dichromates

Potassium dichromate

  • Mungo Ponton (1839); Edmond Becquerel (1840)
  • William Henry Fox Talbot (1852): gelatine hardening
  • allergen; toxic; carcinogenic
  • EU ban (since 2017-09)
  • in same boat: ammonium dichromate

Potassium-dichromate-sample.jpg NH4_2Cr2O7.JPG

Diazidostilbene (DAS)

Disodium 4,4'-diazidostilbene-2,2'-disulfonate tetrahydrate

C14H16N6Na2O10S2

PubChem

Use for carbon transfer:

Charles Berger, Richard Kauffman

(1993, UltraStable process)

Diazidostilbene

Research literature

Further links: gelatine, cross-linking, organic azides etc

2020_Schock_Molecules_25_cover.png

Modelling the process

Cross-linking

Step-growth or chain-growth?

Physical properties as function of degree of hardening?

Spherical cow

M1 model

  • ✓ linear characteristic curve
  • ✓ highlight threshold
  • ❌ contrast ↑ as sensitizer ↓
  • ❌ contrast ↑ as ink ↑

Following up

Any help or suggestion welcome!

THANKS FOR YOUR ATTENTION!